Rocks and Willows
  • Blog
  • About
  • Blog
  • About


“You see, some things I can teach you. Some you learn from books.
​But there are things that, well, you have to see and feel.” 

― Khaled Hosseini, A Thousand Splendid Suns















​
​

​

Rigour: Kids of Steel

3/25/2018

4 Comments

 
    When our two kids were younger, they participated in the Kids of Steel triathlon each year. It seems like a crazy idea, little six year olds swimming and biking and running! And it kind of is, when you consider there is even a 5-and-under category (although they don’t do the swim.) We never forced them to do it. They were just outdoorsy kids and spent a lot of time biking and running, so those two sections were an easy fit. Our daughter was always a competitor and just loved to participate. Our son, two years younger, did it for the little bag of gummy candies that they got at the finish line…and that worked as motivation for more years than it legitimately should have lol.
    We encouraged our kids to try their best, to swim hard, bike fast, and run! But one lesson was always clear: it’s not about first, it’s about finishing.
    It might be a shrunken down version of a triathlon, but it is NOT easy. The eight year olds swim 100m, bike for 5km, and then finish with a 1.5km run. I would suspect that a good portion of the adult population might even struggle at those distances! I always forgot to take pictures before the event, which was unfortunate since the ones afterwards always had exhausted and (frequently) tear-stained faces. But there was a sense of accomplishment amongst the physical pain. They never placed first, but not once in seven years did either of our kids give up and not cross the finish line.
    I’m thinking of triathlon today because my legs hurt. Like the I-can’t-bend-down-to-put-my-shoes-on hurt. I have gone to a few crossfit sessions at a fantastic new gym in town, and it’s totally my own fault that I am out of shape and have sore muscles. (The rowing machine was a killer.) We work through stations as hard as we can, as quickly as we can. The best word that comes to mind is RIGOROUS.
    It’s a funny word, rigorous. I googled it. Merriam Webster’s top definitions are ‘a harsh inflexibility…unyielding…strictness…severity…cruelty...a condition that makes life difficult, challenging, or uncomfortable.’ Yeah, it’s got a negative connotation to it, FOR SURE. Rigorous training. Rigorous obstacles. Rigorous landscapes. So why does rigour keep showing up in things I read about education? Why would we want learning to be harsh, unyielding, or severe?
    That’s a good question, and a more complex answer than one post to do it justice. But more unfortunate is that when we try to make things more rigorous, it usually just means adding more questions to the assignment, making the test longer, extending the word count on that essay. I admit it. I’ve done those things, thinking that it was making it more challenging for students. But if the level of thinking isn’t increasing, and all those questions never get past the most basic regurgitation of facts, it’s simply more repetitive, not more rigorous.
    I saw this on Twitter recently, and it really stuck. “Most people think of rigor as simply meaning harder. It’s not harder; it’s deeper thinking.” Dr. Bill Daggett
    This week, we were given a goal-setting task at our staff meeting. I was challenged to push my own thinking past getting the easy answers. I can tell you, I didn’t like it. Not one bit. And my administrator can attest to the fact that I was likely a bit pouty about it. It was frustrating and it was difficult, and when I was ready to quit the response was, “You’re not allowed. You said that it was important, so you have to challenge yourself to stick with it.” Dammit. Rigour.
    I’m pretty sure my kids felt the same way many times in those triathlons. As a parent, when they were struggling, I cheered a lot. I ran beside them when needed. I reminded them that they just had to finish. As teachers and administrators, we do those same things in our schools too. Our students need us to, especially when things get tough, when their thought processes are challenged, when the easy answer isn't allowed. For me, getting those goals written so that they were both significant and meaningful was a rigorous process, and a deeper one, and it was one that I appreciated when it was done, just like the pride of crossing the finish line.

p.s. There were no tears, I swear, but Mr. Kirk, I’ll be looking for my bag of gummy candies on Monday morning!
Picture
Six years old, Kids of Steel Triathlon, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
Picture
That moment when you realize your administrator actually read your blog! :)
Picture
Posted on the door of my classroom, goal setting based on student responses.
Picture
After I had tweeted out my goal sheet, I was pretty amazed at the traction it got from Calgary to Minneapolis! I think it speaks to the power of listening to students, as well as showing them in tangible ways that we have heard them.
4 Comments
Teresa
3/25/2018 01:17:39 am

I appreciate this article Edla. I have been reading so many articles and twitter articles about education lately as well. I think it it’s so interesting how our perspective can change when we take a step back from what we are looking at. How our perceptions shift when we can make connections to similar situations in different contexts. I try and recognize when things have a negative connotation and ask why. I have also noticed that change and growth are supposed to be uncomfortable and that’s okay- that’s a good thing. Maybe we should make rigor a positive description... couldn’t hurt... although cross fit always will :) Good for you BTW!

Reply
Edla
4/2/2018 11:31:44 am

Thanks for your thoughts Teresa! Maybe it's the ELA teacher in me that gets hung up on words lol. The concept of rigour isn't bad. And it's funny that you say that change and growth are supposed to be uncomfortable...that's just what I was writing about this week. We're on the same wavelength haha!
I think all of these ideas are inextricably tied together. I'll steal someone else's words here: "People define themselves by their status quo so they don't want to change, but then that inhibits growth. We only get better through change."
I think it can also be 'we only get better through challenge' too.

Reply
Paul
4/2/2018 08:36:32 am

Really glad you’re doing this, Edla. I’m including a link to a math example, but I think it speaks to your thoughts on rigor:

http://robertkaplinsky.com/why-depth-of-knowledge-is-critical-to-implement/

Basically, this post is an attempt in math to address the issue of rigor about which you’ve written so convincingly. We likely need to be thinking of depth of knowledge in all subject areas. (Or better yet, combining subject areas and just worrying about depth of thinking. Period.)

Again, good job!

Reply
Edla
4/2/2018 01:26:26 pm

Thanks for the link! I like the videos, and it's interesting to see what happened as it moved into "How did you know?" and then into application in another area. I also agree with your idea of working on the depth of the thinking. For me, I need to focus on the depth-of-thinking within tasks. I can't remember offhand where I read it, but essentially it's not always about the verb choice in an objective but the authentic context it's used in...how deeply students are challenged to think about a task. So although creating or designing or applying are deeper thinking activities, if they don't have meaningful context (or choice or time or challenge?) it's still possible for students to do these in a cursory manner and not have any greater understanding of the topic than the boy in the last video...
Thanks again for sharing!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Perpetual amateur. Lifelong learner. Vice-Principal. Teacher. Musician. Mom. Annnnd if you're reading this, then I'm still a blogger.

    I have a Bachelor of Music in Music Education, and  Master of Education in Educational Technology and Design, both from the University of Saskatchewan. 
    ​
    Edla Landry
    littlewillowsk@hotmail.ca
    edla.landry@spiritsd.ca 
    ​

    Archives

    January 2023
    September 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly